Last Updated on April 2, 2025 by Treana Wunsch
Did you know that a significant number of small business owners feel intimidated by the CRA? The Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) found that over half of small business owners feel like they’re treated as if they’ve done something wrong when dealing with the CRA. And honestly? That tracks with what I’ve seen.
I’ve worked with small businesses for a decade, working with clients across industries. And I’ve witnessed numerous CRA issues—from applying payments to the wrong year to freezing bank accounts with minimal warning. It’s not just stressful, it’s destructive. Small businesses are the backbone of this economy, and these CRA challenges are making it harder for them to survive, let alone thrive.
Between misplaced payments, intensive audits, long wait times, lost paperwork, and confusing tax codes, many business owners aren’t just dealing with red tape—they’re fighting for stability. And here’s the kicker: when mistakes happen, you pay. Twice. Once in wasted time. Again in dollars.
Let me walk you through the challenges I’ve witnessed, and lived through, and share what small business owners like you can do about it.
Cash Flow Struggles for Small Businesses
Cash flow is everything. You can survive a slow month. But it’s extremely difficult when your tax refund gets delayed for months.
One of my clients—a trades contractor—was owed a substantial GST refund. That’s not pocket change. He was told it would be a few weeks. It took several months. And guess what? He had to take out a line of credit, just to make payroll. That refund was his working capital. The delay meant he paid the price—literally, in interest.
Then there’s the client who paid several thousand dollars in taxes on time. But the CRA somehow lost record of these payments entirely. She received alarming notices claiming she owed the full amount—plus mounting interest and penalties. She’s spent countless hours on hold, sent copies of receipts repeatedly, consulted with a lawyer, and even attempted to escalate the issue through formal channels. Despite all these efforts, years have passed and they still haven’t corrected the issue. The payments remain “missing” in their system while the penalties continue to accumulate. Infuriating doesn’t begin to describe it—this is a taxpayer who did everything right, has proof of payment, and yet remains trapped in an administrative nightmare with no resolution in sight.
Worst part? There’s typically no compensation for these kinds of situations. And we’re not just talking about stress here—we’re talking real costs. Accountants, admin time, lost sleep.
If this hasn’t happened to you yet, don’t wait. Triple-check every payment. Screenshot everything. Keep records meticulously. Because unfortunately, you need to be prepared.
I’ve also seen bank accounts frozen with minimal warning. This can happen when following an established payment plan—communication breakdowns occur, and suddenly access to funds is restricted. There may be legal processes in place, but they don’t always work as intended. When something goes wrong, the impact can be severe.
Get 80% off Quickbooks Online
The CRA and Entrepreneurship Challenges
Running a business in Canada shouldn’t feel like you’re doing something suspicious. But that’s exactly how interactions with the CRA can sometimes feel.
A lot of my clients are solopreneurs, tradespeople, creatives—people who took a risk to work for themselves. But the tax system? It’s primarily built for traditional employment. Understanding your obligations as a self-employed person or small business owner can be challenging, and when mistakes happen (even minor ones), the consequences can be significant.
I had one client—a home-based baker who built a loyal customer base from nothing—get hit with an audit the week she planned to expand. The stress nearly crushed her. She had receipts. She had QuickBooks Online up to date. But the audit process dragged on for months, draining her momentum and her confidence.
She told me later, “If I knew it would be like this, I might’ve just kept it as a hobby.” That broke my heart.
This is the real impact. In some cases, these experiences can discourage entrepreneurial ventures.
I have another client who literally panics every time she receives a letter from the CRA, even when it’s just a regular Notice of Assessment. Despite doing everything by the book—meticulous record-keeping, timely filings, honest reporting—she’s developed an almost visceral fear of those government envelopes. That kind of anxiety shouldn’t be part of running a legitimate business.
If you’re starting out, here’s what I tell every client:
- Keep your books clean from day one.
- Hire a bookkeeper and accountant you trust.
- Don’t wait until tax time to think about taxes.
- Have a CRA buffer fund. Seriously.
Because as inspiring as it is to chase your dream, you need to prepare for the administrative realities.
Impact on Tax Compliance
This is where things get interesting.
The CRA aims to ensure tax compliance. But in some cases, overly aggressive enforcement tactics or disproportionate penalties may inadvertently push some businesses toward non-compliance.
I’ve seen it happen. A trades business I worked with faced a reassessment after a bookkeeping error—and the reassessment significantly increased what they supposedly owed. They struggled to pay it. The pressure led them to consider taking cash jobs.
I’m not saying it’s right. But I am saying it happens.
When the tax system feels overwhelming, some people look for ways to avoid it. That’s the reality. Complex requirements, unclear policies, and intensive audits create anxiety. Anxiety leads to avoidance for some.
If we want better compliance, here’s what would help:
- Simplify the system.
- Make penalties more proportionate.
- Create an atmosphere of compliance support rather than assuming wrongdoing.
My favourite digital tools for small business
Considerations for Canada's Competitiveness
Let’s zoom out.
If you were an international company looking to set up in Canada, complex tax administration could be a factor in your decision-making process. While Canada has many advantages for businesses, administrative burdens can impact attractiveness.
I had a client exploring a partnership with a U.S. firm. The deal became complicated when the American side realized the potential for retroactive assessments going back several years. That uncertainty was a complicating factor.
Meanwhile, other countries are working to streamline tax compliance to attract business. We should be doing the same.
Administrative efficiency can play a role in making it easier for Canadian businesses to grow internationally.
Want to keep talent and innovation here? A more straightforward, supportive tax system would help.
Administrative Inefficiencies and Their Impact
This one hits a nerve.
You expect government agencies to have some administrative challenges, right? But the inconsistencies can be overwhelming.
You can call multiple times and get different answers. I once called with a client and asked a question about payroll deductions. The first agent gave one answer. We weren’t sure, so we called again. The second agent gave a different answer. By the third call, we were told to submit a request in writing—and wait several weeks. Not to mention, each call to CRA takes a minimum of an hour.
This stuff matters. Inconsistent guidance can lead to costly mistakes.
Add to that: lost documents, misplaced forms, and errors in assessments. These things happen, and when they do, businesses often need to pay professionals to help resolve the issues.
This isn’t just inefficient. It’s expensive. And it’s frustrating.
The Cost of Resolving Administrative Issues
Let’s talk dollars.
When incorrect notices are sent, paperwork is misfiled, or assessments contain errors, it sets off a chain reaction. Bookkeepers get pulled in. Accountants start charging by the hour. Phone calls. Letters. All of that costs money.
I’ve had clients spend significant amounts cleaning up situations that originated with administrative errors. And typically, these expenses aren’t reimbursed.
This is why I tell all my clients: invest in prevention.
- Keep your records meticulous.
- Use accounting software.
- Save everything to the cloud.
- Set aside an audit fund, just in case.
While mistakes don’t happen in every case, when they do occur, they can be costly in both time and money.
The Administrative Burden on Business Owners
If you’ve ever tried to submit documentation to the CRA, you already know: it can be challenging.
The forms. The portals. The passwords. The hold times.
One of my clients spent many hours gathering documents for a routine audit. Not because she had anything to hide, but because they wanted extensive documentation—receipts, invoices, bank statements, client contracts—covering several years. She was running a small landscaping company with limited administrative resources.
I’ve seen audits triggered by minor discrepancies. I’ve seen businesses get flagged because their filings didn’t match by insignificant amounts.
Small business owners sometimes feel like they’re presumed non-compliant until proven otherwise. Meanwhile, larger corporations have dedicated tax departments or hire specialized firms to manage their tax planning.
If the CRA wants to better support small business, they could:
- Scale audit requirements proportionately to business size.
- Create clearer, more user-friendly documentation.
- Improve their portal functionality and consistency.
Right now? Dealing with the administrative processes is like having another job. And that’s work that doesn’t generate revenue.
Tuesday Takeaways Newsletter
A Call for Reform
Let’s be clear: The CRA serves an essential function in our society. But administrative challenges, inconsistencies, and sometimes disproportionate enforcement actions are creating real hardships for small businesses.
It’s not just annoying—it’s impactful. Because when small businesses struggle, the broader economy feels the effects.
We need thoughtful tax administration reform. We need processes that recognize the realities of small business operations. We need systems that are efficient, human-centered, and designed for entrepreneurs in the real world.
And it makes me wonder: Who’s auditing the auditors? The CRA scrutinizes our every financial move, demands meticulous documentation, and penalizes the smallest mistakes. But when they lose payments, misapply funds, or provide contradictory information, there’s often little accountability.
Yes, Canada does have a Taxpayer Ombudsperson tasked with ensuring the CRA respects taxpayer rights and provides appropriate service. But this office has limited power. The Ombudsperson can make recommendations, but cannot overturn CRA decisions. Many of my clients who’ve attempted to use this service have found the process time-consuming and ultimately ineffective for resolving their specific issues.
The annual reports highlight systemic problems year after year, yet the same issues persist. It’s a layer of oversight that often lacks the teeth needed to drive meaningful change or provide timely relief to businesses caught in administrative nightmares. Perhaps it’s time not just for an Ombudsperson who can identify problems, but for a system that can actually enforce accountability when the CRA fails to meet its own standards of service.
If you’ve had your own challenging CRA experiences, share them in the comments. I also want to hear about the good experiences! I want to believe some positives come out of CRA. Let’s advocate for meaningful improvements—and maybe create positive change.
Because we’re not just taxpayers. We’re builders. And we deserve a system that works with us, not against us.
